同事主动变革行为对员工组织公民行为的消极影响机理研究The Mechanism of Negative Effect of Coworker Taking Charge Behaviors on Employee Organizational Citizenship Behaviors
赵瑜
摘要(Abstract):
组织变革和可持续发展越来越多地依靠个体主动变革实现,主动变革行为逐渐受到理论界的广泛关注,但现有研究忽视了同事主动变革行为对员工自身潜在的消极影响。鉴于此,文章基于资源保存理论视角,通过构建有调节的中介模型,分析来自5家中小型科技公司328份上级主管-下属配对的3阶段调查数据,阐释同事主动变革行为对员工自我损耗及组织公民行为的作用机理。结果表明,当同事展现更多主动变革行为时会引起员工的自我损耗;同时,随着员工自我损耗程度的增加,员工组织公民行为会减少,即员工自我损耗在同事主动变革行为与员工组织公民行为的关系中起中介作用;此外,员工感知的高承诺人力资源实践能有效削弱同事主动变革行为对员工自我损耗的正向影响,并且使员工自我损耗在同事主动变革行为与员工组织公民行为之间的中介作用得到减弱。
关键词(KeyWords): 资源保存理论;主动变革行为;自我损耗;组织公民行为;高承诺人力资源实践
基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金重点项目“共享理念下的多元雇佣:合作型人才管理理论建构与作用机理研究”(71832003);; 广东省教育厅科研项目“共享理念下的内部企业:内部创业团队激励机制研究”(2018GWQNCX058)
作者(Author): 赵瑜
参考文献(References):
- [1] JUDGE W,DOUGLAS T.Organizational change capacity:the systematic development of a scale[J].Journal of Organizational Change Management,2009,22(6):635-649.
- [2] MORRISON E W,PHELPS C C.Taking charge at work:extra role efforts to initiate workplace change[J].Academy of Management Journal,1999,42(4):403-419.
- [3] KIM T Y,LIU Z Q,DIEFENDORFF J M.Leader-member exchange and job performance:the effects of taking charge and organizational tenure[J].Journal of Organizational Behavior,2015,36(2):216-231.
- [4] 张征,李锦.员工主动变革行为:前因与后果[J].中国人力资源开发,2019,36(5):60-75.
- [5] LOVE M S,DUSTIN S L.An investigation of coworker relationships and psychological collectivism on employee propensity to take charge[J].International Journal of Human Resource Management,2014,25(9):1208-1226.
- [6] WU C H,DENG H,LI Y.Enhancing a sense of competence at work by engaging in proactive behavior:the role of proactive personality[J].Journal of Happiness Studies,2016(19):1-16.
- [7] FULLER J B,MARLER L E,HESTER K.Bridge building within the province of proactivity[J].Journal of Organizational Behavior,2012,33(8):1053-1070.
- [8] ZHANG M J,LAW K S,WANG L.The risks and benefits of initiating change at work:social consequences for proactive employees who take charge[J].Personnel Psychology,2021,74(4):721-750.
- [9] BOLINO M,VALCEA S,HARVEY J.Employee,manage thyself:the potentially negative implications of expecting employees to behave proactively[J].Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology,2010,83(2):325-345.
- [10] LIN C C,KAO Y T,CHEN Y L,et al.Fostering change-oriented behaviors:A broaden-and-build model[J].Journal of Business and Psychology,2015,31(3):399-414.
- [11] 杨陈,唐明凤,景熠.关系型人力资源管理实践对员工主动变革行为的影响机制研究[J].管理评论,2019,31(12):207-218.
- [12] KIM T Y,LIU Z Q.Taking charge and employee outcomes:the moderating effect of emotional competence[J].International Journal of Human Resource Management,2017,28(5):775-793.
- [13] FRESE M,FAY D.Personal initiative:an active performance concept for work in the 21st century[J].Research in Organizational Behavior,2001(23):133-187.
- [14] DOGAN K,VECCHIO R P.Managing envy and jealousy in the workplace[J].Compensation and Benefits Review,2001,33(2):57-64.
- [15] WANG Q,WANG J,ZHOU X,et al.How inclusive leadership enhances follower taking charge:the mediating role of affective commitment and the moderating role of traditionality[J].Psychology Research and Behavior Management,2020(13):1103-1114.
- [16] HOBFOLL S E.Conservation of resources:a new attempt at conceptualizing stress[J].American Psychologist,1989,44(3):513-524.
- [17] HOBFOLL S E.The influence of culture,community,and the nested-self in the stress process:advancing conservation of resources theory[J].Applied Psychology:An International Review,2001,50(3):337-421.
- [18] 赵琛徽,翟欣婷,蔡婷.工会实践对员工组织公民行为的影响机制:心理契约和高绩效人力资源实践的作用[J].经济管理,2021,43(3):194-208.
- [19] XIAO Z,BJ?RKMAN I.High commitment work systems in Chinese organizations:a preliminary measure[J].Management and Organization Review,2006,2(3):403-422.
- [20] BOON C,KALSHOVEN K.How high-commitment HRM relates to engagement and commitment:the moderating role of task proficiency[J].Human Resource Management,2014,53(3):403-420.
- [21] JEROEN M,ANNA B N,JAN D L.How employees’ pro-activity translates high-commitment hrm systems into work engagement:the mediating role of job crafting[J].International Journal of Human Resource Management,2018,31(22):1-26.
- [22] MEIJERINK J,BONDAROUK T.Uncovering configurations of HRM service provider intellectual capital and worker human capital for creating high HRM service value using fsQCA[J].Journal of Business Research,2018,82(3):31-45.
- [23] FAY D,HüTTGES A.Drawbacks of proactivity:effects of daily proactivity on daily salivary cortisol and subjective well-being[J].Journal of Occupational Health Psychology,2017,22(4):429-442.
- [24] OU Y K.Taking charge as a double-edged sword:understanding its bene?ts and costs from a resource perspective (Doctoral Dissertation)[D].Hong Kong:The Hong Kong Polytechnic University,2016.
- [25] 张永军,廖建桥,赵君.国外组织公民行为与反生产行为关系研究述评[J].外国经济与管理,2010,32(5):31-39.
- [26] CUDDY A J,GLICK P,BENINGER A.The dynamics of warmth and competence judgments,and their outcomes in organizations[J].Research in Organizational Behavior,2011(31):73-98.
- [27] 王忠军,袁德勇,龙立荣.工作中自我损耗的来源、影响与应对研究探析[J].外国经济与管理,2013,35(2):71-80.
- [28] FREEMAN N,MURAVEN M.Don’t interrupt me! task interruption depletes the self’s limited resources[J].Motivation and Emotion,2010,34(3):230-241.
- [29] 戴云,田晓明,李锐.管理者主动变革行为对工作幸福感的双刃剑效应研究[J].中国人力资源开发,2021,38(4):54-66.
- [30] GRANT A M,PARKER S,COLLINS C.Getting credit for proactive behavior:supervisor reactions depend on what you value and how you feel[J].Personnel Psychology,2009,62(1):31-55.
- [31] BAUMEISTER R F,GAILLIOT M,DEWALL C N,et al.Self-regulation and personality:how interventions increase regulatory success,and how depletion moderates the effects of traits on behavior[J].Journal of Personality,2010,74(6):1773-1802.
- [32] 卫武,黄昌洋,张琴.消极情绪对组织公民行为和反生产行为的影响:自我控制视角[J].管理评论,2019,31(12):146-158.
- [33] WOOD S,MENEZES L D.High commitment management in the U.K.:evidence from the workplace industrial relations survey,and employers’ manpower and skills practices survey[J].Human Relations,1998,51(4):458-515.
- [34] XIAO Z,TSUI A S.When brokers may not work:the culture contingency of social capital[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,2007,51(1):1-31.
- [35] JIANG K,LEPAK D P,HU J,et al.How does human resource management influence organizational outcomes?A meta-analytic investigation of mediating mechanisms[J].Academy of Management Journal,2012,55(6):1264-129.
- [36] COLLINS C J,SMITH K G.Knowledge exchange and combination:the role of human resource practices in the performance of high-technology firms[J].Academy of Management Journal,2006,49(3):544-560.
- [37] JOHNSON R E,LANAJ K,BARNES C M.The good and bad of being fair:effects of procedural and interpersonal justice behaviors on regulatory resources[J].Journal of Applied Psychology,2014,99(4):635-650.
- [38] LEE K,ALLEN N J.Organizational citizenship behavior and workplace deviance[J].J Appl Psychol,2002,87(1):131-142.
- [39] BERNERTH J B,AGUINIS H.A critical review and best-practice recommendations for control variable usage[J].Personnel Psychology,2016,69(1):229-283.
- [40] CARLSON K D,WU J.The illusion of statistical control variable practice in management research[J].Organizational Research Methods,2012,15(3):413-435.
- [41] CAMPBELL E M,LIAO H,CHUANG A,et al.Hot shots and cool reception?An expanded view of social consequences for high performers[J].Journal of Applied Psychology,2017,102(5):845-866.
- [42] FASBENDER U,BURMEISTER A,WANG M.Motivated to be socially mindful:explaining age differences in the effect of employees’ contact quality with coworkers on their coworker support[J].Personnel Psychology,2019,73(3):407-430.
- [43] WELBOURNE T M,JOHNSON D E,EREZ A.The role-based performance scale:validity analysis of a theory-based measure[J].Academy of Management Journal,1998,41(5):540-555.
- [44] FASBENDER U,WANG M.Intergenerational contact and hiring decisions about older workers[J].Journal of Managerial Psychology,2017,32(3):210-224.
- [45] AULAKH P S,GENCTURK E F.International principal-agent relationships:control,governance and performance[J].Industrial Marketing Management,2000,29(6):521-538.
- [46] 王莹,邓慧,蓝媛媛.同事无礼行为对员工工作退缩行为的影响:基于归属需求理论视角[J].中国人力资源开发,2020,37(12):45-57.
- [47] DUFFY M K,GANSTER D C,PAGON M.Social undermining in the workplace[J].Academy of management Journal,2002,45(2):331-351.
- [48] TICE D M,BAUMEISTER R F,SHMUELI D,et al.Restoring the self:positive affect helps improve self-regulation following ego depletion[J].Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,2007,43(3):379-384.
- [49] MOLLER A C,DECI E L,RYAN R M.Choice and ego-depletion:the moderating role of autonomy[J].Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,2006,32(8):1024-1036.
- [50] VEN N V D,ZEELENBERG M,PIETERS R.Appraisal patterns of envy and related emotions[J].Motivation and Emotion,2012,36(2):195-204.
- [51] GRANG A M,GINO F,HOFMANN D A.Reversing the extraverted leadership advantage:the role of employee proactivity[J].Academy of Management Journal,2011,54(3):528-550.
- [52] NISHII L H.The benefits of climate for inclusion for gender-diverse groups[J].Academy of Management Journal,2013,56(6):1754-1774.